416-703-2402 Local
1-888-378-3388 Toll Free

Posts Tagged: motion

Motion for Refusing to Answer Questions at Examinations for Discovery: Factors to Consider

In civil litigation, party litigants must proceed to the question-answer process of an Examination for Discovery, during which time many questions will be asked of a party.

The issue of whether you “must” or “have to” answer a specific question very frequently arises. Specifically, plaintiffs often wonder whether a series of questions improperly inquires about personal / intimate matters or whether the questions are off-base from the subject matter of the lawsuit. For example, many of my clients initially wonder “why are they asking me about that, aren’t we talking about how they caused this car accident?”.… Continue Reading

Tags: , , ,

Designating a Person as a Party Under Disability in Ontario

An interesting illustration of the type of process that is to be undertaking in order to have a party litigant, in a civil litigation lawsuit, designated as a ‘party under disability’ against their will: York Condominium Corporation No. 301 v. James, 2014 ONSC 908.

This case involves a condominium corporation seeking certain relief against the defendant, who occupies a unit in the condo. Allegations include that the defendant is unfit to care for herself (i.e. sleeping in stairwell) and may be a danger to herself and others (i.e.… Continue Reading

Tags: ,

Defence Medical Assessments from Rear-End Car Accident: How Many Do You Have to Attend?

The Issue: One question many car accident victims have when they start a lawsuit is how many medical examinations they will have to submit to during the course of their lawsuit. The Rules of Civil Procedure allow for one medical assessment, with the defendant(s) having then to seek the plaintiff’s consent or a Court order for any further assessments. In reality, the Court will generally allow the defendant to match a plaintiff in terms of expert medical reports.

When can the defendant’s insurance company force you to undergo further defence medical examinations, when you’ve already been examined by their chosen psychiatrist and physiatrist?… Continue Reading

Tags: , , ,

Faster Lawsuits > Practice Reminder: Tickler System for Service of Statement of Claim

A busy litigation practice involves juggling priorities and managing the deadlines which naturally occur in each lawsuit.

One requirement, designed to move lawsuits forward, is to serve the defendants formally with your Statement of Claim within six months of issuance.

If you fail to and do not obtain consent from the defendant, then you have to bring a motion seeking a Court order extending the time for service of the Statement of Claim past six months, as happened in: Bernardo v.… Continue Reading

Tags: ,

Settle Out of Court for $80,000; Fight in Court Over $1400

Litigation arising from a motor vehicle accident tends to be difficult for all parties involved, particularly with the stress of a lawsuit ‘hanging’ over your life. Sometimes you just wish that the other side would ‘see the light’, be reasonable and agree to resolve the lawsuit.

In some instances, litigation becomes fairly heated between the parties and counsel involved, so that both sides are simply not prepared to negotiate or compromise any further. The limit has been reached and there is no sense in more discussion.… Continue Reading

Tags: , ,

10 Year Old Lawsuit Faces Motion To Dismiss for Delay: A Close Call Averted

If your lawsuit is not moving forward in an expeditious manner, the defendants can bring a motion to dismiss for delay, as occurred in this recent case: Mayhew v. Paddon + York Inc., 2014 ONSC 57 (CanLII).

In this case, the allegations against the plaintiffs included failure to comply with several previous Court orders, as well as a delay in answering undertakings arising from Discovery.

Judge Morawetz lays out the test to consider as follows:

[28] The court’s authority to dismiss an action for delay is found in Rule 24.01 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, R.R.O.… Continue Reading

Tags: , ,